I was standing in Waterloo Station today, and on the large TV screen above the concourse, an exultation to end poverty flashed up.
I thought a little about the statement.
So yes – we could end poverty. But let’s think deeper.
It’s a sine curve out there. Most things are. There will always be left hand side that is below average. Doesn’t matter how steep the slope is but of course it’s worse if the slope is really shallow.
The way to reduce poverty is to move the curve up to the right. How you do that is to enable those on the left to move towards the middle of the sine curve. So how does a global economy do that ?
OK – so if I knew that, I’d go and do it, but I’m not conviced that a bunch of very well off rock stars have any real impact on how people from the middle to right hand side of the curve see their role in all of this.
Fairtrade looks a pretty good deal. It means that more money is passed directly to the producer. There was a programme on the BBC the other day about the Indonesian prawn farmers. I was trying to work out how it works so that the farmers gets a miniscule percentage of the final price. How many middle layers are there of people making a profit from pushing prawns around the world ? Is this a good way of alleviating poverty in Indonesia ( just to use this as an example ) ?
Seems that what we shoudl be doing is helping them build business locally , and developing a local economy that is not dependant. I know, I know, this then suggests that they don’t focus on exporting luxury stuff to the West, and everyone thinks this is the way to do it.
But think more. They aren’t getting anywhere near enough money from this process, and, even worse, when the developed world find out that food miles, uncontrolled farming practices and extremely poor working conditions in the developing world are a problem, we’ll all be looking to buy local and grow our own ( It’s already happening in the UK with many more people growing their own green beans rather than importing from Africa, where water is scarce )
Again, people in Kenya make money from Europeans buying green beans, but surely we can help them build their own local market for their own indiginous crops ?
Which reminds me.
Isn’t fashion and money a horrible combination.
Why, when South America has the fantastic potato as a source of carboydrate, do they import rice ? Fashion and status ?
And why does India now insist on having meat as a major part of their diet ? Just because they have more money so they can ?
Both of these actions are pretty bad for the planet, truth be known.
And yes, I know that everyone wants what the other guy has – I just think that clean water, sanitary conditions and a local economy is probably more of the right way to stable and suitable future.
We’ll see